Blu-ray review: “Johnny Handsome” (1989)

“Johnny Handsome” (1989)

Action

Running Time: 104 minutes

Written by: Ken Friedman based on The Three Worlds of Johnny Handsome by John Godey

Directed by: Walter Hill

Featuring: Mickey Rourke, Ellen Barkin, Elizabeth McGovern, Forest Whitaker, Scott Wilson, Lance Henriksen and Morgan Freeman

Rafe Garrett: “You got a real nice face now don’t you, Johnny? But I think I liked it better the old way. Yeah, and I think I can help you get it back.”

Critical Commentary

Released in 1989, “Johnny Handsome” is a neo-noir crime drama directed by Walter Hill. The film offers a gripping narrative that delves into themes of identity, transformation, and redemption. Starring an impressive ensemble cast including Mickey Rourke, Ellen Barkin, Morgan Freeman, and Forest Whitaker, the movie takes audiences on a journey through the life of Johnny “Johnny Handsome” Mitchell, a disfigured career criminal who seeks a chance at a new life.

Set in the gritty underbelly of New Orleans, “Johnny Handsome” tells the story of Johnny Mitchell (Mickey Rourke), a small-time criminal with a misshapen face, a result of a childhood accident. His appearance has always garnered him unwanted attention, leading him to a life of crime. However, his fate takes a turn when he is betrayed by his partners in a heist and sent to prison. In prison, Johnny meets a sympathetic surgeon, Dr. Steven Fisher (Forest Whitaker), who offers him a chance at a new face and, consequently, a new life. After undergoing extensive plastic surgery, Johnny emerges with a new face and a newfound hope for a better future. But the question remains: Has his physical transformation truly changed him? Can he escape his criminal past and start anew?

As Johnny is released from prison, he attempts to live a straight and narrow life, finding work and reconnecting with his childhood friend Donna McCarty (Ellen Barkin). However, the past catches up with him as his former criminal associates, led by Rafe Garrett (Lance Henriksen), discover his whereabouts and coerce him into participating in another heist. As Johnny becomes entangled in a web of deception and danger, he must navigate a treacherous path to ensure his survival and protect those he cares about.

At its core, the film examines the concept of identity and how it can be altered or transformed. Johnny’s physical transformation prompts him to confront questions about his true self. He grapples with the idea that changing his appearance might not be enough to escape his criminal past and redefine his identity. This theme challenges audiences to consider whether genuine change is simply a matter of external transformation or if it necessitates a deeper internal shift.

Johnny’s desire for redemption serves as a driving force throughout the film. Despite his criminal history, he yearns for a chance to start anew and leave his past behind. The film suggests that everyone deserves a second chance, raising questions about society’s willingness to forgive and offer opportunities for rehabilitation.

As Johnny becomes embroiled in another heist, the film explores ethical dilemmas and the shades of grey that define morality. Johnny is forced to make difficult choices to protect himself and his loved ones, blurring the lines between right and wrong. This theme underscores the complexity of human nature and the decisions individuals make when faced with adversity.

The relationship between Johnny and Donna reflects the enduring power of friendship and loyalty. Donna stands by Johnny’s side despite his criminal past and disfigurement, embodying unconditional support. Their connection adds a layer of emotional depth to the narrative and highlights the significance of genuine connections in a world fraught with deceit.

“Johnny Handsome” embraces the conventions of the neo-noir genre, characterized by its moody lighting, dark themes, and morally complex characters. The film’s visual style, characterized by shadowy scenes and evocative cinematography, enhances the sense of intrigue and suspense.

The film places a strong emphasis on character development, allowing the audience to connect with Johnny and the other characters on a deeper level. Mickey Rourke’s performance as Johnny is particularly noteworthy, as he effectively conveys the character’s internal struggles and transformation.

The film’s setting in the grimy underbelly of New Orleans adds to its gritty realism. The city’s distinct architecture, along with its mix of poverty and opulence, serves as a backdrop that reflects the characters’ motivations and the challenges they face.

Hill’s skilful direction maintains a taut sense of tension throughout the film, heightening the stakes as Johnny becomes entangled in a dangerous game. The well-paced narrative keeps audiences engaged, as twists and turns unfold, revealing the complexities of Johnny’s predicament.

“Johnny Handsome” received mixed reviews upon its release, with praise directed toward the performances and the film’s exploration of themes. Mickey Rourke’s portrayal of Johnny was particularly acclaimed for its depth and vulnerability. While the film didn’t achieve widespread commercial success, it garnered a cult following and continued to be appreciated for its unique blend of neo-noir aesthetics and character-driven storytelling.

Beyond its initial reception, “Johnny Handsome” remains relevant due to its exploration of timeless themes. The idea of transformation, both physical and psychological, continues to captivate audiences. The film’s examination of the potential for redemption and the complexities of morality resonates with viewers who appreciate narratives that challenge conventional notions of good and evil.

“Johnny Handsome” holds a unique place within the crime drama genre, largely due to its focus on character-driven storytelling and its willingness to explore complex themes. One of the film’s strengths lies in its ability to balance gritty crime elements with introspective character development. Mickey Rourke’s portrayal of Johnny Mitchell is a central element that contributes to the film’s impact. Rourke’s performance captures Johnny’s internal struggle as he grapples with his identity, past mistakes, and newfound opportunities.

The film’s exploration of physical transformation as a catalyst for internal change is a theme that remains relevant in various forms of media. In “Johnny Handsome,” the physical alteration of Johnny’s appearance prompts audiences to question the relationship between external appearances and internal transformation. This theme resonates with the broader human experience of striving to overcome personal limitations and embrace change, both physically and emotionally.

The moral ambiguity present in the film challenges conventional notions of right and wrong. By placing Johnny in morally compromising situations, the film highlights the complexity of human decisions, especially when individuals are pushed to their limits. The choices Johnny makes are not always straightforward, showcasing the nuanced decisions that shape his path. This portrayal of moral dilemmas adds depth to the narrative and encourages viewers to reflect on their own beliefs about ethics and justice.

Walter Hill’s direction contributes significantly to the film’s atmosphere and narrative impact. His use of neo-noir aesthetics, such as low-key lighting and atmospheric visuals, creates a moody and evocative backdrop that enhances the film’s themes. Hill’s emphasis on character development allows the audience to empathize with Johnny’s struggles and triumphs, fostering a deeper emotional connection to the story.

The film’s supporting cast also plays a vital role in its success. Ellen Barkin’s portrayal of Donna McCarty adds emotional resonance to the narrative. Her unwavering support for Johnny, despite his criminal past and physical appearance, underscores the film’s themes of friendship and loyalty. Morgan Freeman’s performance as Lt. A.Z. Drones, a detective investigating Johnny’s criminal activities, provides a counterpoint to Johnny’s character. Freeman’s portrayal brings a level of gravitas to the film, adding complexity to the dynamics between law enforcement and criminals.

Despite its initial mixed reception, “Johnny Handsome” has endured over the years as a cult classic. Its themes of identity, transformation, and redemption continue to captivate audiences and prompt discussions about the nature of change and the power of second chances. The film’s exploration of the gray areas of morality and the challenges of making difficult choices remains relevant in a society that often grapples with complex ethical dilemmas.

“Johnny Handsome” may have been released in 1989, but its themes and messages continue to resonate in today’s society. The film’s exploration of identity, transformation, redemption, and morality remains highly relevant, reflecting the ongoing complexities of the human experience.

In the digital age, questions of identity have taken on new dimensions. Social media platforms allow individuals to curate their online personas, often presenting an idealized version of themselves. The concept of transformation—both physical and emotional—has expanded to encompass the digital realm, where the boundaries between real and constructed identities blur. “Johnny Handsome’s” exploration of how identity can be both fluid and constrained by external factors resonates with the contemporary discourse surrounding online identities.

Second Chances and Rehabilitation: The idea of second chances and rehabilitation remains a significant societal concern. The criminal justice system continues to grapple with issues of recidivism, reintegration, and the potential for personal transformation. “Johnny Handsome’s” depiction of Johnny’s desire for redemption prompts discussions about the capacity for change and society’s role in supporting individuals seeking to rebuild their lives after making mistakes.

In an increasingly interconnected and globalized world, ethical dilemmas have become more complex. The film’s portrayal of moral ambiguity reflects the nuanced decisions individuals face when confronted with difficult choices. Contemporary society often grapples with ethical questions related to technology, politics, and social issues. “Johnny Handsome” encourages viewers to consider the motivations behind people’s actions and to empathize with their struggles to navigate grey areas.

Society’s obsession with appearance and beauty standards persists, with media and advertising often promoting unrealistic ideals. The film’s central focus on Johnny’s disfigurement and subsequent transformation invites viewers to reflect on how appearance influences perceptions of self-worth and interactions with others. This theme remains pertinent in conversations about body positivity and the societal pressures to conform to narrowly defined beauty norms.

The pursuit of redemption remains a universal aspiration. In a world marked by personal and collective struggles, stories of personal growth and transformation offer hope and inspiration. “Johnny Handsome’s” exploration of Johnny’s journey to overcome his past resonates with narratives of resilience and the human capacity to overcome adversity, making it a narrative that continues to captivate audiences seeking stories of redemption.

The film’s portrayal of the friendship between Johnny and Donna underscores the importance of genuine connections in a world that can often feel isolating. In an era dominated by technology and virtual interactions, the film’s emphasis on authentic relationships is a reminder of the value of human connection and the support we can offer to one another.

“Johnny Handsome” transcends its release year and continues to hold cultural and thematic significance in the present day. Its exploration of identity, transformation, redemption, and morality resonates with contemporary discussions about technology, ethics, personal growth, and the human experience. The film’s enduring relevance is a testament to its thoughtful storytelling, complex characters, and willingness to engage with profound themes that transcend time and societal changes. As long as audiences continue to engage with and reflect upon these universal themes, “Johnny Handsome” will remain a cinematic work that offers insight, introspection, and a powerful narrative that stands the test of time.

“Johnny Handsome” stands as a testament to the enduring power of storytelling in film. Through its exploration of identity, transformation, redemption, and morality, the movie transcends its neo-noir roots to offer a thought-provoking and emotionally resonant experience. Walter Hill’s direction, coupled with a strong cast led by Mickey Rourke, creates a cinematic journey that remains relevant and impactful, inviting audiences to contemplate the nature of change, the pursuit of redemption, and the intricacies of the human experience.

Technical Commentary

Video

“Johnny Handsome” which like the previous two discs says is sourced from a new 4K master. This may be the case but it’s not a crystal clear winner. To be fair, this movie has never looked great on disc and has generally been rather rough to ugly to watch. Details are much better than I’ve seen before allowing you to appreciate Rourke’s work under all that makeup but those fine details don’t quite pop either. Fine lines can have a bit of a crunchy quality to them.

Audio

“Johnny Handsome” has a very good LPCM 2.0 track. Much like “Extreme Prejudice”, the film has long stretches of simple conversations so there’s not a lot of call for a full-bore multi-channel surround track.

Special Features